Back to List

Notes and Reflections on Books and Media

by Hannah Leitheiser

Loses their Minds

Citizens: A Chronicle of the French Revolution

Simon Schama

1990

Link

2018-02-23

Anarchy scares most people, and perhaps it should, but I think it's still an open question whether people are up to self-government. If it's possible, a good anarchy would require people mostly emotionally and intellectually ready to be governments of one, able to operate on commonly respected protocols for interfacing each little decentralized governmental node.

The French revolution was mostly vandalism of government out of hungry desperation, to be replaced by groups or individuals acting on their fear of those against true patriots, vagabond mobs, and signals of forces of invasion.

The author makes the claim several times that most people wanted more government, not less, assuming such provided bread at reasonable prices.